• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Innovative Manufacturers Center

Driving Manufacturing Growth and Job Creation in Central Pennsylvania

(570) 329-3200
  • Careers
  • IMC Blog
  • News
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
    • IMC Service Area
    • IMC Team
    • Success Stories
    • Central PA Manufacturing Companies
    • Partners & Network
    • Career Opportunities
    • Contact Us
  • Services
    • People
      • Brand Development
      • Business Continuity Planning
      • Elevating HR Practices for Manufacturing Success
      • Environmental & Safety Compliance
      • Lean Manufacturing User's Group
      • Manufacturing Business Growth Services
      • Sales Development
      • Tooling U-SME
    • Processes
      • Continuous Improvement
      • International Trade & Export Compliance
      • ISO 9001 Certification
      • ISO Support
      • Lean Manufacturing Level One Practitioner Certification
      • Lean Manufacturing Transformation
      • Problem Solving with Root Cause Analysis
      • Supply Chain Optimization
    • Technology
      • Advanced Manufacturing Technologies for Modern Manufacturers
      • Clean Energy Manufacturing
      • Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC)
      • Digital Marketing & SEO
      • SMART-PA
      • Technology Scouting
      • Website Design
    • Innovation
      • Innovation Engineering Systems
      • Manufacturing Innovation
      • R&D Tax Credits
      • Technology and Innovation
      • Williamsport/Lycoming KIZ
        • About the Williamsport/Lycoming KIZ
        • Do I Qualify for the KIZ?
        • KIZ Tax Credits
        • Williamsport/Lycoming KIZ Benefits
        • Williamsport/Lycoming KIZ Services
  • Events
  • Training
    • People
      • Meeting the HR Challenge
    • Processes
      • ISO 9001 Certification
      • Lean Manufacturing Level One Practitioner Certification
      • Problem Solving with RCA

How to Bring Back Manufacturing Jobs

image_pdfPrint PDFimage_printPrint

(strategy+business – Daniel Gross: 9-7-16)   America has a long-running crisis in manufacturing employment. Quite simply, year after year, the number of people employed in making things declines — the figure is down by nearly 5 million since 1996. And in election years like this one, it is common to hear politicians talk about how they will bring manufacturing jobs back.

Across the board — on both sides of the aisle, in every part of the country — there is an overwhelming desire to have more manufacturing jobs. This is partly due to nostalgia and symbolism. But it’s also driven largely by economics: Generally speaking, the manufacturing jobs that have been lost (and that remain) offer better pay, benefits, and job security than the service jobs that have replaced them. What’s more, manufacturing has a big multiplier effect — when you build machines at a factory, it calls an array of suppliers and service providers into action. Thanks to the power of manufacturing’s economic impact, states and cities are often willing to offer significant financial incentives to companies that are willing to open plants.

Now, if they were being honest, politicians would note that the vast majority of the millions of manufacturing jobs lost can’t return. They left due to globalization and competition. And many were rendered obsolete by technology. The reality is that the value and volume of stuff factories produce tends to rise each year, even if employment falls, because software, machines, and computers are doing more of the work.

However, there are at least a few hundred thousand manufacturing posts that could be “brought back” without turning back the clock on globalization and making factories less productive. All that would have to happen is for America’s companies to fill the hundreds of thousands of open positions.

I’ve written before about the strange state of affairs in the job market. Markets everywhere have become more efficient, thanks to technology and brilliant new platforms that grant buyers and sellers of goods and services the ability to meet one another online and agree on product and prices. And yet the labor market has become less efficient. As the most recent JOLTS report notes, there were some 5.6 million jobs open in the U.S. at the end of June, up from 2.4 million in June 2009. If human resources professionals could be 10 percent more effective at filling posts than they are, there would be an additional 560,000 people working today.

Last week, the Wall Street Journal noted that a decent chunk of those openings are in manufacturing. “The number of open manufacturing jobs has been rising since 2009, and this year stands at the highest level in 15 years, according to Labor Department data,” the Journal reported. “Openings for manufacturing jobs this year have averaged 353,000 a month, up from 311,000 in 2015 and 122,000 in 2009.” That’s a lot!  There are 12.28 million manufacturing jobs total in the U.S., and in the past year, 39,000 have been lost.

To put it differently: If U.S. manufacturers were willing and able to fill the positions they have open, we’d be bringing manufacturing jobs back in a big way.

So why isn’t it happening? How can it be that the number of manufacturing openings has tripled in the past seven years even as millions of manufacturing workers have been forced to find other work? Well, it’s complicated.

Markets may be efficient most of the time, but they’re far from perfect. It could be that there are lots of openings in geographic regions where the population has been declining. It could be that employers, who have to compete for labor in ways they haven’t had to in more than a decade — the unemployment rate is just 4.9 percent — aren’t offering enough money to lure workers away from their current jobs.

But in manufacturing, there’s something else at work. As the Journal noted, the manufacturing industry has changed a great deal in recent years. It is more technology-intensive, more specialized, and depends on higher-value-added goods. As is the case with many other professions — including journalism and retail — the jobs have evolved to the point where they are fundamentally different. It’s one thing to weld a fender to a car body; it’s quite another to program, manage, and maintain the machines and robots that do the welding. All of which is to say that the level of skills and competencies manufacturing employers are seeking in their employees may be significantly higher than the level they were seeking 10, or 20, or 30 years ago.

In most instances, especially in service industries such as retail and food service, labor shortages can be solved by the simple application of higher wages. But when it comes to manufacturing, higher wages may be only part of the solution. Sure, you can entice a skilled operator of machine tooling to walk across the street by doubling her salary. But if the market — i.e., other companies, the educational system, and training programs — hasn’t been endowing sufficient numbers of workers with those skills, higher pay will only get you so far.

The most direct way to bring back manufacturing jobs, then, may be for companies to decide that they are prepared to invest in programs or direct efforts that will produce workers with the skills they need. The solution to outsourcing production elsewhere may be to insource training.

(Daniel Gross is executive editor of strategy+business.)

image_pdfPrint PDFimage_printPrint

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

Search

Blog Categories

  • IMC Blog
  • News
  • Success Stories

Blog Archives

Testimonials


“Through the Winning Teams program, we increased throughput in our laminate cleaning/inspection area by 18%, which also shortened the time for us to respond to vendors about defective products and t… Read more

Northway Industries, Inc.


“We’re very pleased with the results of the training. It was a great way to break the ice regarding a systemic change in one of our oldest and most experience facilities. By training on change man… Read more

Bo PrattPresidentRockland Manufacturing Co.


The IMC and its staff have played an integral part in the success of Pik Rite’s Continuous Improvement culture as well as directly influencing more efficient production and operations. The proof is … Read more

Caleb ThomasProduct Line ManagerPik Rite, Inc.


We are a small organization and do not have IT staff. Before we found IMC, the task to implement CMMC seemed almost insurmountable. With their help, the process was no longer overwhelming, and we were… Read more

Terry KnouseVice President of OperationsNuVisions Center


5 Whys, SIPOC, Value Stream Maps, etc. are great ways to visualize problems that are difficult to pinpoint.

Brandon SmithQuality Control Lead TechnicianSilcoTek


The attendees of both training programs came away energized and eager to apply their new skills in training, coaching and communications. There is broad consensus that these skills should continue to … Read more

Jeanette WraggTraining ManagerPrysmian Group


We make investments where and when our workforce is skilled and ready.  The training was a solid foundation for supervisor development.

Steve PrentissVice President of Human ResourcesNittany Paper Mills, Inc.


The Value Stream Mapping exercise conducted by the IMC enabled us to visually see the overall production process and the areas we needed to target for improvement. Without this process, QCast may not … Read more

Terry ArnoldGeneral ManagerQCast Aluminum


IMC’s resource consultant’s background and knowledge were so relevant, and his delivery set a solid foundation upon which we could build for our re-certification as well.

Robert LangOwnerLang’s Chocolates


“IMC has been an excellent resource for us to accomplish objectives that we would not have been able to achieve on our own. We would highly recommend any company taking full advantage of the services … Read more

Marc DagataPresidentMetal Integrity




Newsletter Signup

Sign up for IMC’s newsletter to get the latest news on manufacturing in Central Pennsylvania.

"*" indicates required fields

By providing your email, you agree to receive future email correspondence from IMC.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.









Upcoming Events



Jul


9


11:00 am – 11:30 am


Learn More About the Technology Showcase at Shale Insight Conference



Jul


17


11:00 am – 11:30 am


Energy Industry Overview Map – Onshore Wind Energy



Jul


17


2:00 pm – 3:00 pm


Mastering CMMC Assessments: What You Need to Know



Jul


31


11:00 am – 11:30 am


Energy Industry Overview Map – Data Centers: Overview of Market Potential



Aug


21


11:00 am – 11:30 am


Energy Industry Overview Map – Battery Storage


View Calendar


News

IMC President is Guest Speaker on “Risk-Based Decision Making in a Time of Uncertainty” Podcast

IMC President, Dennis Gilbert had the honor of joining the kickoff episode of Survive and Thrive—a timely podcast series featured on The Quality Hub. In this first episode, Dennis joins hosts Xavier Francis and …

Read More

Central Susquehanna WSCM School Honored at Statewide Manufacturing Awards

As Central Susquehanna WSCM’s Best of PA nominees, Mount Carmel Area and Huntingdon Area Middle Schools recently joined IMC’s Lauri Moon, Manager of the Central Susquehanna WSCM program, at the What’s So Cool About Manufacturing® …

Read More

What’s So Cool About Manufacturing Video Contest Announces 2025 Central Susquehanna Awards

IMC is excited to announce the award recipients for the “What’s So Cool About Manufacturing?” (WSCM) Central Susquehanna student video contest awards.  The annual awards ceremony was held April 23rd at The Venue at Liberty …

Read More
Copyright © 2025 IMC, Inc - Site Developed by Pineapple PC
One College Avenue, Dept. 32 Williamsport, PA 17701-5799